Commentary on the economy, the markets, and business

Is Microsoft going the way of the Zune?

Fortune's Jon Fortt reports that when long-time Microsoft-basher Larry Ellison (the CEO of Oracle) was asked this week if Microsoft was still relevant, his answer was:

They make a lot of money. I think they're clearly relevant. I divide the computer industry into two groups. And I know for a long time I was constantly picking a fight with Microsoft. Now Oracle's constantly picking a fight with IBM. Because you've got to pick your enemies very carefully, because you're destined to become most like those enemies you select.

Microsoft, culturally now, is a very consumer-centric company. They've got the Xbox. They've got Zune. … I think they are obsessed with Apple (AAPL). They're obsessed with Google. … Under the new administration at Microsoft, I see all of their energies going into being successful in the consumer space.

Adam Lashinsky, who pointed me to Fortt's post, says Ellison may be exaggerating a bit (exaggerate? Larry Ellison?!?) but is still onto something. Microsoft's profits come mostly from business-oriented software (Windows, Office, Outlook, etc.), but its dominance in all those areas is under assault. So it's been trying to succeed in the consumer space, with limited success and even-more-limited profits. And now Larry Ellison seems to think IBM is the bigger force to reckon with going forward.

That's two major instances of IBM emulation in a week. What's up with that?

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (2)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    It's certainly an understandable comment by Ellison, but it's not reflective of Microsoft's goals. Remember, this is a company that thought it could dominate any market it entered, as long as it got the products right. It came to believe that there was little growth left for it in the business markets, and a decade or so ago started turning to what it believed remained a fast-growth area - consumer electronics. It's not clear whether they now believe they haven't gotten the products right yet, or whether it is a quagmire that they can't win, but either way they can't retreat and write off all of that investment.

    But I wouldn't under any circumstances call Microsoft a consumer electronics company. It is a marketing company that concentrates on technology.

  • 2

    I disagree. I think MS is trying to focus on multiple markets at once because they have the resources to do that and they have real concerns about the future. They were taken largely unaware by the internet - and remember their response put them in the dock with not only our government but all of Europe. They are rightly concerned they can't see into the future and can't know what might come at them so they spend money, which they have in abundance, to make sure they're in those spaces.

    As to the Zune, they've done a good job of learning from Apple - and let's be honest, it's much easier to take someone else's work and try to refine that - but I'm not sure even they believe the Zune really matters as a music player. I think they have the money* to spend on this small device because they don't know if that will generate a more existential threat or a bigger opportunity.

    *MS is more constrained by talent of all kinds, from writers to managers, than by money. That issue, that it's hard to manage so many ventures well, may become their biggest problem.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
The Curious Capitalist Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's The Curious Capitalist in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
LORI HAAS, whose daughter was wounded in the 2007 Virginia Tech shootings, on a new report finding that officials warned their families more than an hour and a half before the rest of the campus and released locked-down students who were later killed