Commentary on the economy, the markets, and business

You, too, are to blame for your credit-card debt

I'm already getting hate mail for having suggested that Americans' epic struggle with credit-card debt isn't entirely the fault of big, bad credit card companies. Guess that's not what we're in the mood to hear.

The irony is that if you actually read my story past the headline (which I didn't write), you'll see that I'm giving credit-card users something of a free pass. It's not lack of will power that's the issue, but our own faulty cognitive wiring. Here, it will be easier to excerpt and link:

The problem with the credit-card industry isn't just credit-card companies — it's you too. This week the Senate takes up a bill that would seriously clamp down on some of the industry's most unsavory practices, a piece of legislation that President Obama has said he wants on his desk by the end of the month...

Credit-card companies, though, may not be the only ones we need to be protected from. Every penny of Americans' nearly $1 trillion in revolving debt started with someone — some individual person — whipping out a piece of plastic and making a decision to use it. We could consider that free will and just call it a day, but there's plenty of reason to believe the story isn't so simple. There are piles of evidence that people are bad decision makers when it comes to how they use credit cards. Even when presented with full and fair information, they often make decisions that are not in their own economic best interest — a reality only partly taken into account by the new rules and pending legislation...

The solution I get to, after documenting some of the economically irrational ways we use credit cards, is disclosure that makes the cost of credit real to people. Not real as in telling them, but real as in telling them so that they understand. It's an idea I stole from these guys. One of whom now works for the President. Hm.

You can read the rest of the story here.

Barbara!

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (4)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    whoever is responsible for that headline should be taken out back and smacked around a bit, Barbara.
    _
    The "stupid" stuff that credit card holders do isn't (generally) a random occurrence, rather they are the result of policies and promotions of credit card companies that encourage stupid actions based on known behavioral/psychological principles.
    _
    IMHO, credit card companies are deliberately creating "attractive nuisances" -- the equivalent of putting in a swimming pool in your back yard. If you do that, you're required (in most towns) to put a high fence around it to prevent problems that are likely to occur because the swimming pool is there. Credit card companies should be required to take the same kinds of steps to make sure that the only people who abuse their credit cards are doing so with the knowledge and intent that they are doing something wrong.

  • 2

    How about this for plain English credit card company explanations: "We are offering you the loan of some money that is ours, not yours. You have to pay it back, but at such a high interest rate that you will end up owing us a lot more than you borrowed. We will also let you carry at least a part of the loan principal for years, if you like, in which case you would owe us still more. If you miss a payment, for whatever reason, we will sock you with stiff penalty charges. Are you sure you still want to do this? (Y/N)"

  • 3

    @Barbara: Um, my wiring made me do it?

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
The Curious Capitalist Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's The Curious Capitalist in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
CORINNA LANKFORD, one of the 10 American Baptists detained in Haiti on child trafficking charges