Commentary on the economy, the markets, and business

Did John Thain lose his job because he acted like it's still 2007?

As Wall Streeters go, John Thain had done a pretty impressive job of maintaining his reputation amid the financial carnage of the past couple years. But I'm starting to wonder if any of the Wall Street establishment is going to come out of this mess looking even remotely respectable.

Thain had risen through the ranks at Goldman Sachs. When it became clear that he wasn't going to rise to the very top of those ranks, he took over as CEO of the New York Stock Exchange and orchestrated a surprisingly peaceful transition into the modern electronic era. Then he went to Merrill Lynch to clean up the mess that Stan O'Neal had made, sold out just in time to Bank of America, and seemed to win the confidence of B of A CEO Ken Lewis.

Scratch that last part. Today—with the play-by-play reported by Charlie Gasparino on CNBC—Lewis hauled Thain into his office and fired him. The biggest issue was clearly Merrill's $15 billion in fourth quarter losses and, according to the WSJ, Lewis's aggravation that he didn't hear about them from straight from Thain. But there was some other stuff too:

The Bank of America CEO also concluded Mr. Thain has exercised "poor judgment" on a number of fronts. He left for a vacation in Vail, Colo., after the losses came to light, bonus payments at Merrill were accelerated so they could be collected before the end of the year and Mr. Thain had planned to fly this week to Davos, Switzerland, even though Bank of America had signaled that such a trip was not a good idea ...

Plus this from Gasparino:

Thain spent $1.22 million of company money to refurbish his office at Merrill Lynch headquarters in lower Manhattan. The biggest piece of the spending spree: $800,000 to hire famed celebrity designer Michael Smith, who is currently redesigning the White House for the Obama family for just $100,000.

My impression is that this is all basically stuff that top Wall Street executives do. Or at least have done. I really think most of them—even the pretty smart ones like Thain—still don't get how much smaller and poorer and less popular their industry is likely to be in the coming years.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (6)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    Did John Thain lose his job because he acted like it's still 2007?

    sort of. My guess is that he was fired because he made some enemies who had the documentary proof (which Gasparino cites in his article) that Thain spent lavishly on himself, and were going to go public with it. Here are two prime 'leak' suspects (from the Gasparino piece)...

    Thain has come under pressure in recent weeks after several top executives at Merrill, including brokerage chief Bob McCann and investment banking head Greg Fleming, abruptly resigned from the firm citing differences with Thain

    I don't buy the "$15 million dollar loss" explanation, not when BoA got billions from Paulson to "buy" Merrill Lynch (" $138 billion in government assistance, including the infusion of $20 billion from the federal government"). I mean, lets face it, whats another $15 million when you're talking billions of dollars. And lest we forget, those losses were made public a month ago.

    Basically, it looks like Lewis fired Thain because Thain was about to become the poster boy for financial industry executive excess, and a public embarrassment for BoA look bad, and Lewis knows he's going to have to have to go back to the public trough before this is all over. (Indeed, one suspects that Lewis might be trying to pre-empt questions about his own lavish spending....)

  • 2

    Let's not forget about the $10 million bonus he attempted to award himself at the end of 2008, too.

  • 3

    YOU'RE JOHN THAIN
    (You're so Vain, Carley Simon)
    WilliamBanzai7

    You waltzed into the Bail Out party
    Like you were sailing on an unsinkable yacht
    Your hat strategically dipped below one eye
    Your scarf it was really hiding a mega Merrill subprime surprise
    You had one eye on the Level III mirror
    As you watched yourself gavotte
    And all those second rate Charlotte Bankers dreamed that they'd be your partner
    They'd be your partner, and

    You're John Thain
    And yes this song is about you
    Don't complain
    I'll bet you thought B of A could'nt live without you
    Without you? Without you?

    You had Ken Lewis several months ago
    When he was so naive its hard to believe
    Well, you said that the Thundering Herd would make an awesome notch on his sleeve
    And that you John Thain would never leave
    But you gave away the things you loved
    And one of them was a 10 Million Dollar bonus snub
    And good ol Ken's grandiose dreams turned out to be clouds in his bailout coffee
    Clouds in his bailout coffee, and

    You're John Thain
    And yes this song is about you
    You're John Thain
    I'll bet you thought B of A couldn't live without you
    Without you? Without you?

  • 4

    Banker Conversations
    (WilliamBanzai7)

    KEN: Nice carpet John, should I take of my shoes?

    JOHN: Use the slippers by the door.

    KEN: I hear their selling Bernie's fleet. Some nice hardware there.

    JOHN: The guy is a seedy low life crook, he belongs behind bars.

    KEN: Come on John, don't be so hard on the man. He's like all of us in a sense.

    JOHN: Have a seat KEN (Pointing to COMMODE ON LEGS)

    KEN: Man this place make my digs look like a Japanese bankers office.

    JOHN: (Sitting in George the IV Chair) Dozo Ken-san. Every Wall Street Shogun has his castle.

    KEN: So you got your bonus after all?

    JOHN: How so?

    KEN: You gave it to all your friends down the hall and spent the pre-installment on this fancy french hardware.

    JOHN: You like that eh? It's what we in the business call an AIG omelet.

    KEN: You know John, I think I am going to go over and have a look at Bernie's fleet.

    JOHN: Shall I join you. You know China Fun is just down the block from his place.

    KEN: No John, you stay here and pack this stuff up while I'm gone.

    JOHN: Pack?

    KEN: Yes, pack. I want you on the street by 5 PM.

    JOHN: I don't even have any shrink wrap!

    KEN: The only shrink wrap you need is Dr. Schadenfreude rapping the "Bailout shuffle"

    JOHN: See you in bailout hell Ken.

    KEN: We are already there John. We are already there.

    [One hour later]

    BERNIE: Ken, you have my sympathy. People just don't appreciate the Ponzi business model in all its subtle manifestations.

    KEN: Skip the sermon Bernie, I'll take em all.

  • 5

    guess they'll have to toss a tarp over Thain's new office furniture

  • 6

    KENNY THE BAILOUT MOOCHER
    (Minnie the Moocher, Cab Calloway)
    WilliamBanzai7

    Sing along link: http: KENNY THE BAILOUT MOOCHER
    (Minnie the Moocher, Cab Calloway)
    WilliamBanzai7

    Sing along link: Cab Calloway

    Hey folks here's the story bout Kenny the bailout moocher
    He was a low down Charlotte BAC hoochie coocher
    His was the roughest toughest banking sob tale
    But Kenny had an appetite as big as a securitized whale

    Hidehidehidehi (hidehidehidehi)
    Hodehodehodeho (hodehodehodeho)
    Hedehedehedehe (hedehedehedehe)
    Hidehidehideho (hidehidehideho)

    He messed around with a bloke named Thain
    He wanted the Merrill Bulls or he'd go completely insane
    Thain took him round to Chinatown
    And showed old Kenny how Wall Street gangstas kick the gong around

    Hidehidehide-LEVEL 3 (hidehidehidehi)
    Whoah (whoah)
    Hedehedehede-GREED (hedehedehedehe)
    A hidehidehideho CDO (hidehidehideho)

    Kenny had a dream bout yet another financial supermarket
    It would give him things that he was needin
    It would give him a palace built of gold and steel
    A diamond studded learjet with platinum wheels

    A hidehidehidehidehidehidehi (hidehidehidehidehidehidehi)
    Hodehodehodehodehodehodeho (hodehodehodehodehodehodeho)

    Thain sold Ken a herd of sick cows and a boatload of subprime losses
    Each meal Ken ate was full of surprising new derivative courses
    Had a billion dollars worth of taxpayer nickels and dimes
    He sat around and counted them all a million times

    Hidehidehide-LEVEL 3 (hidehidehidehi)
    Hodehodehode-CDO (hodehodehodeho)
    Hedehedehede-GREED (hedehedehedehe)
    Hidehidehide-HOSED (hidehidehideho)

    POOOOOOR MAN
    POOOOOOOOOOOOOOOR MAN
    POOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOR MAN

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
The Curious Capitalist Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's The Curious Capitalist in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
LORI HAAS, whose daughter was wounded in the 2007 Virginia Tech shootings, on a new report finding that officials warned their families more than an hour and a half before the rest of the campus and released locked-down students who were later killed