-
ADD TIME NEWS
- NEWSLETTERS
- Main
- Best iPhone Apps
- Global Business
- Small Business
- Curious Capitalist
- Techland
- It's Your Money
- Money & Main Street
- Videos
Neue Kolumne: Obamas große wirtschaftspolitische Kurswechsel
I've got a brief piece in today's Der Standard, everybody's favorite pink Austrian newspaper. It begins:
Die USA haben im 20. Jahrhundert zwei große wirtschaftspolitische Kurswechsel erlebt —Franklin Roosevelts New Deal und die Reagan-Revolution in den Achtzigerjahren. Die Ankunft von Barack Obama im Weißen Haus in Zeiten des Finanzkollapses und einer tiefen Rezession erscheint wie eine weitere große Wende. Am stärksten werden sich das Sozialwesen und die Haltung der USA gegenüber dem Rest der Welt ändern. Read more.
And in case you'd rather read it in English, here's the text I sent to my friend and Der Standard's managing editor Eric Frey to translate (I thought about trying to write it in German myself, but that might have taken me two or three days):
The United States went through two economic regime changes in the 20th century—Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal in the 1930s, and the Reagan Revolution in the 1980s. The arrival of Barack Obama in the White House amid financial collapse and severe recession has the feel of another sea change in U.S. economic policy. Two of the areas most likely due for transformation are the welfare state and the international stance of the U.S.
The U.S. built a generous system of health care and pensions in the 1940s and 1950s, but did it through corporations, not the government. That safety net is now tattered, with its biggest provider, General Motors, on government life support. So a new approach to managing medical and retirement risks, with government playing a more central role (if perhaps still not as central as in most of Western Europe), is likely to be one defining element of this new economic era in the U.S.
Another may be international cooperation. Fixing financial regulation will be an early Obama priority, and just as high finance crosses borders its regulation will have to as well. Similar considerations will factor into environmental and perhaps labor regulation. After World War II, the U.S. embraced international institutions, but from a position of dominance. A re-embrace now would be a very different sort of endeavor—and would amount to a big change in how the world works.
-
1
The United States went through two economic regime changes in the 20th century—Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal in the 1930s, and the Reagan Revolution in the 1980s. The arrival of Barack Obama in the White House amid financial collapse and severe recession has the feel of another sea change in U.S. economic policy.
_
wow, don't you think that this is a gross exaggeration?
_
both the changes undertaken by FDR and Reagan had their origin in the "new" economic theories -- For FDR, it was interventionism (aka Keynesian), for Reagan it was Supply Side. Obama shows no sign of adopting any kind of new economic theory (other than rejecting 'bushonomics'). Indeed, his advocacy of tax cuts suggests that he still accepts much of supply side orthodoxy.
_
the point here is that Obama never articulated any rationale in terms of economic policy -- it was all boilerplate. Indeed, there is no evidence that he has any real understanding of the relationship between the federal government and the economy -- certainly he didn't study it in school, and his two years in the Senate before he started running for President did not provide him with working knowledge.
_
People grossly exaggerate the significance of Obama's election, because Bush was such a horrorshow. But "not being Bush" is not a sign of being an innovative thinker who is going to redefine everything (although the media will portray it that way). Obama is just some kind with no real experience, a good campaign manager, and a journalistic establishment behind his candidacy. -
2
@plukasiak: Sowas sagt nur ein bitterer Republikaner.
-
3
@plukasiak: Also, there was no coherent economic philosophy behind FDR's policies. It was just frenzied improvisation in the face of economic collapse. Keynes's "General Theory" didn't come out until in 1936, and Keynesianism didn't really take off in the U.S. until after World War II.
-
4
plukasiak has numbed him/herself so much there is no ability left to perceive a sea change as it is happening
-
5
Keynes's "General Theory" didn't come out until in 1936, and Keynesianism didn't really take off in the U.S. until after World War II.
_
that's why I called it interventionism, and put "keynesian" in quotes!
_
The point is that while the end of the Bush era is more than justification for celebration, this idea that Obama represents something other than 'not Bush' is silly. Obama is getting the same kind of treatment that Bush got after 9-11, and you'd think that people (especially the media) would realize that simply because there's a crisis doesn't make our leadership a figure of transcendent wisdom.
_
here's a question -- do you think that had it been Bill Clinton taking over, that things would be worse than under Obama? Do you think that Obama's approach will be fundamentally better than Hillary Clinton's had she won? If so, please explain why. -
6
I'm inclined to agree with plukasiak, although I also believe that the most powerful tool that any sitting president possesses is the bully pulpit. The president has the unique ability to set the national attitude and outlook, no matter what the external circumstances.
-
7
Grossartig, vor allem «die Haltung der USA gegenüber dem Rest der Welt» ist wichtiger denn je.
Grüsse aus Berlin (einem Teil des Restes der Welt)
Matt
Most Popular »
- Obama Below 50 in Gallup, What it Means
- Modern Warfare 2: This %$#ing Game is #$%ing %^ed Up
- What Would Jesus Buy?
- NASA’s Newest, Meatiest Spokesman: The Rock
- Black Friday: What We Know So Far
- Oprah: Who Wins? Who Loses? And Is She Really Quitting?
- CA Sen Poll: Boxer Maintains Lead
- Civil Disobedience, Religious Right-Style
- 1,000 Words: Clean-Up Edition
- 20 Money-Saving iPhone Apps
- Can These Parents Be Saved: The Growing Backlash Against Over-Parenting
- Flibanserin Drug: Will 'Female Viagra' Boost Sex Drive?
- 'New Moon' Movie Review: Jacob Ascends in 'Twilight' Sequel
- Three Key Lessons from Obama's China Tour
- Hey Ireland, Please Drop the World Cup Do-Over
- The Story of Barack Obama's Mother
- Tuition Hikes: Protests in California and Elsewhere
- Dangerous Game: The Next Round of the U.S.-Iran Nuclear Face-Off
- It's Twilight in America: The Vampire Saga
- Teary Oprah Announces End of Show But Is the Time Really Right?














RSS