Monday, January 12, 2009 at 6:57 pm
Sharks rampage in Australia. Let's bring in a statistician.
All day long the top story on Time.com has been this one about a spike in shark attacks in Australia. It starts:
Swimmers at Australian beaches are usually reassured by statistics that indicate they are more likely to be struck by lightning than chomped by a shark. But after three non-fatal shark attacks in the country in less than 48 hours and a deadly one last month, some are wondering if the odds have changed — and whether Australia's efforts to protect sharks are to blame.
As a member of the mainstream media that brought you the Summer of the Shark, I'm a little sensitive to shark-attack hype. Rory Callinan, our man down under, does a really good job deflating the notion that sharks are suddenly out to get us and we need to go kill them.
In an effort to help him out, and reproduce a cool chart I saw in this book, I'd like to mention a study of smoking in Montana that was published in the British Medical Journal a few years ago. The city of Helena had a 6-month smoking ban, during which the number of people showing up to the local hospital because of a heart attack fell by 40 percent. When the ban ended, the number went back up. Cause meets effect? It's tempting.
But here's the chart:

Those little asterisks signify years when the number of heart-attack deaths varied by around 30 or 40 percent. I know the data doesn't line up perfectly with hospital admissions, but still it's the sort of thing we might want to consider before we go shark hunting in Australia. Sometimes a data blip is just a blip.
Barbara!
1 Comment or Trackback to “Sharks rampage in Australia. Let's bring in a statistician.”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
- Adam Lashinsky
- Barry Ritholtz
- Brad DeLong
- Calculated Risk
- Econbrowser
- Econlog
- Epicurean Dealmaker
- Ezra Klein
- Felix Salmon
- Floyd Norris
- Greg Mankiw
- James Pethokoukis
- John Gapper
- Marginal Revolution
- Mark Thoma
- Matt McAlister
- Megan McArdle
- Michael Mandel
- Mike Moffatt
- Nicholas Carr
- Paul Kedrosky
- Philip Coggan
- Roger Parloff
- Ryan Avent
- Sarah Palin to Quit as Alaska Governor
- What Happened To the Stimulus?
- Michael Jackson Gets His Requiem
- Afterbirth: It's What's For Dinner
- Why British Health Officials Say Swine Flu is Nothing to Party About
- Does the E.U.'s Airline Blacklist Make Flying Safer?
- Pakistan Hopes for Answers on Bhutto Murder
- While Canada Spends Big to Save GM, Mexico Gets Free Ride
- This Preposterous Week! Paul Slansky's News Index
- How California's Fiscal Woes Began: A Crisis 30 Years in the Making
- Inside Michael Jackson's Neverland Ranch
- U.S. Marines Open a New Offensive in Afghanistan
- The History of the Bikini
- Photos: India's Contraband Wildlife
- Photos: A Madoff Family Album
- Michael Jackson: The Last Photos
- Public Enemy: The Extremely Brief and Violent Life of John Dillinger
- Photos: Sacha Baron Cohen's Outrageous BrÜno Promotions
- The World's Ugliest Dog Show
- Party On with the G-8!
Monday, February 16, 2009 at 3:54 am
My children and I have just watched Sharkwater, a documentary decrying the extensive hunting of sharks for fins.
They suggest that up to 100 million sharks a year are being killed for this harvest, and that population numbers have fallen by 90%.
The kids are all right now in the process of writing letters supporting the banning of shark hunting.
A film well worth watching. http://www.sharkwater.com
Simon Winfield