Nobody knows anything about macroeconomics
Arnold Kling writes:
My daughter who is a freshman left a message that she wants me to explain macro to her. I can do that, in the sense that I can teach what is in her textbook. In reality, however, macro is a muddle that no one can explain. The undergraduate textbook, a graduate textbook, and macroeconomics as practiced by policymakers (what Mankiw calls the "engineering approach") have nothing in common with one another.
Every macroeconomic pronouncement should be accompanied by a disclaimer that says, "This is just my opinion. We don't really know."
When I started writing about the economy for Fortune, in the mid-1990s, I got the sense that most everybody--in government, in academia, etc.--knew this about macroeconomics. Fine-tuning the economy was impossible to do well, the thinking went, so the Fed should just stick to keeping inflation low and Congress and the White House should focus on long-term economic incentives (or just stay out of the way).
Now, with the economy in trouble, lots of people suddenly feel like something has to be done. And maybe something does have to be done. But there's nothing remotely approaching a "scientific" consensus on what that something ought to be. It's just people making half-informed (or less than half-informed) guesses. Isn't that reassuring?
-
1
Half-informed seems wildly optimistic.
However, fear not..More TAD policies contained herein...
The TAD Mortgage Solution Plan
Whenever a mortgage goes into default, the asset would be transferred to The TAD Agency, with no reimbursement to the lender or the borrower. The TAD Agency would rent out the home to borrowers at market rates and would sell home once they moved out. This would discourage companies from making stupid loans since they are guaranteed 0 return if they do. People already shouldn't be taking out stupid loans, but at least this way they arent homeless. No one can complain that we are creating a moral hazard this way. The TAD Agency would be prohibited from any other economic activity other than disbursing dividends and salary to Mr. TAD.The TAD Tort Reform Plan
The current process of damages plus punitive continues - however, all punitive damages are awarded 50/50 between the state and the federal government, with a 1% slice for lawyers and a 1% slice to Mr. TAD for patent rights on the idea for 17 years. This eliminates conservative complaints that individuals win the lottery and that overly aggressive lawyers push marginal cases just for settlement while still maintaining financial incentives to do the right thing to companies. -
2
I like The TAD Tort Reform Plan, but The TAD Mortgage Solution Plan is similar to the way I actually bought my house. The previous owner was unable to meet the mortgage payments and was about to be foreclosed, so some other company acquired the mortgage and rented the house back to them, thus allowing the family to remain in the same house. But they decided to move the next year anyway, so we bought their house and the company received the proceeds to cover the cost of the mortgage plus a fixed profit - the previous owners got anything over that. So the previous owner was able to remain in the house and didn't lose all their equity, that company made a nice 1-year return, the bank didn't have to deal with a foreclosure and auction, and we got a house at a nice price. A win-win-win-win situation!
- TIME Another oil spill? Oil found leaking after rig explosion in Gulf | http://su.pr/1MHcHk - 1 hour ago
- TIME Not a joke: Church will bless your blackberry | http://su.pr/1Y6SaF - 2 hours ago
- TIME Medical marijuana: The first commercial airs in California | http://su.pr/8KvYfY - 3 hours ago
Most Popular »
- The Crimes and Misdemeanors of Meghan McCain
- The Discovery Gunman: TV as the Enemy, and as the Weapon
- A Few Thoughts on the God-Awful State of Customer Service
- Is red-hot India too hot?
- Hits and Misses from Today's Apple Announcement
- 18 Android Apps To Get You Started
- Call of Duty: Black Ops Multiplayer Offers Theater Mode, Wagering and More
- The 10 Tiny Details that Made Star Wars Matter
- Health Reform is Good for Small Business Employees
- The Obama Speech
- Tony Blair in 'A Journey': On U.S. Leaders Bush, Clinton
- Heavy Drinkers Outlive Nondrinkers, Study Finds
- Why Israelis Don't Care About Peace with Palestinians
- How Barack Obama Became Mr. Unpopular
- Study: Young, Single, Childless Women Earn More Than Men
- The Science of Ambition: How Genes, Family Affect Success
- Why France Is Deporting 700 Roma, or Gypsies, to Romania
- Arizona's Anti-Immigration Firebrands: Fueled by Out-of-Staters
- How Can a Democracy Solve Tough Problems?
- Cause of Death: Sloppy Doctors
Quotes of the Day »
RSS
