Commentary on the economy, the markets, and business

Real estate starts to pull the economy down

The August drop in employment that the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported this morning surprised a lot of people. You can't really blame them: It was the first monthly decline since 2003, the numbers had been moderately strong in recent months, and the survey was conducted in the first half of the month, missing a couple of very troubled weeks in the real estate and financial worlds. But that the train wreck that is the real estate industry was eventually going to start hurting the overall economy seems pretty obvious when you look closely at the numbers.

I constructed my own makeshift measure of real estate employment by adding together five BLS job categories: "residential building," "residential specialty trade contractors," "real estate," "building material and garden supply stores," and "credit intermediation and related activities." I realize that I'm catching some people not directly involved in real estate here, particularly in the last category, which includes banks, thrifts, and other lenders. But most of the growth in lending in the first half of the decade was in mortgage and home-equity loans, so I don't think it's too far off.

The real estate industry, as I've added it up, only accounts for 6.6% of American jobs. But between January 2001 and May 2006, when real estate employment peaked, it accounted for an amazing 46% of new jobs. Since then the real estate sector has shed 132,000 jobs while the rest of the economy continued to chug along. The August BLS numbers may indicate that this happy disconnect has ended.

For a dramatic graphic illustration of the phenomenon, here's a chart--made beautiful by Time.com graphics guru Feilding Cage--of employment growth (and shrinkage) in the real estate sector and the rest of the economy:
realestate.gif

Update: Now mortgage lender Countrywide says it's going to cut 12,000 jobs in the next three months. This is just getting started, I think.

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (7)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    I see few comments from your last bunch of posts, so I thought you might like to know someone is reading!

  • 2

    Justin, you know I'm always a loyal reader. The info here is excellent, and its good to see the numbers clearly. Now I was wondering what are your thoughts on the likeliness of the Fed lowering the interest rates - and if you think its a good idea?

  • 3

    It's starting to look like they'll have to cut rates on Sept. 18, and I think they should. This has the feel of a genuine economic slowdown, and in that case it's the Fed's job to ease up a bit.

  • 4

    The question, in retrospect of course, is whether it's too little, too late. Will history say that this Fed sat on the sidelines while the economy went to the dump?

  • 5

    The lesson of the past three decades is that a Fed chairman who wants to keep his job for a while should (a) get his recession out of the way early in his tenure and (b) do so just before the White House appears likely to change hands anyway. It worked for Greenspan and it worked (sorta) for Volcker. I'm not saying that's why Bernanke has acted the way he has, but I do think it may work out well for him in the long run.

  • 6

    The economy is not being pulled down. A few people suffer and everyone acts like money is worthless now. Only fools go broke when 'the economy is down'. Those people were not meant to have money anyway.

  • 7

    A recession is part and parcel of the capitalist creative destruction cycle since it weeds away the inefficient dross. Postponing recessions until a later time as Greenspan was famous for simply postpones the day of reckoning until later and then it's worse.

    So, like it or not, we may have a recession.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
The Curious Capitalist Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's The Curious Capitalist in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
CORINNA LANKFORD, one of the 10 American Baptists who are detained in Haiti on child-trafficking charges