Commentary on the economy, the markets, and business

Meanwhile, where David Beckham wasn't ...

redbull.jpg

At the Red Bull New York-New England Revolution game Saturday night. (The Mighty Revs won 1-0 on what the replays showed to be a beautiful Andy Dorman goal; I missed it because I was text-messaging Mrs. Curious Capitalist). Attendance wasn't really as dire as it appears in the above photo. Presumably to make things look better for the TV cameras, Red Bull ticket sellers cram people into the north stand:

redbull2.jpg

Reported attendance was 13,819. Which looks really lame in Giants Stadium, but wouldn't be bad for a hockey game, a basketball game--or a soccer match in most smaller European nations.

Amid David Beckham's grand entrance in California Friday, there was lots of jabber on the TV and elsewhere about whether Becks could either "save" soccer in the U.S. or vault it into the ranks of the NFL and MLB. Meanwhile, there's been tons of dismissive talk in especially the English media about how Major League Soccer is miles below the top European leagues in quality.

But to become a permanent and successful part of the American sports scene, all that MLS really has to do is become a bit more popular than the NHL and field teams good enough survive in a second-tier European league like the Dutch Eredivisie. This is an age of niche entertainment, and the MLS can do just fine economically merely by broadening its existing niche a little.

Soccer already has a much bigger fan base than hockey here. It's just that most of those soccer fans think the MLS is too low rent or too Anglo for them. There's also a big talent pool of American players; it's just that many of the most talented young ones would rather try their luck in Europe than use the MLS as a springboard.

Will David Beckham's arrival change any of that? How the heck am I supposed to know? He will, definitely this year and probably for the next two or three, bring out lots of people to MLS games who have never been before. And he will sell tons of L.A. Galaxy merchandise. Especially to his relatives, as the Washington Post's intrepid sports blogger (or bogger) Dan Steinberg learned Friday:

I should note that I stopped into the team store to look around, and suddenly the place was locked down and Posh Spice was standing a few feet away from me, snapping up Beckham merchandise. Soccer balls, warm-ups, jerseys. The final tally came to $583 and change. She saw me writing down her purchases.

"We've got to look good for the first game, right?" she told me. "We've got three boys, myself, my sister, my sister's children, my brother, my dad, David's family." I asked how many t-shirts she was buying.

"A lot," she said. "We've got a lot of family."

  • Print
  • Comment
Comments (5)
Post a Comment »
  • 1

    I agree that MLS doesn't need Beckham to "save" soccer -- there are plenty of soccer fans in the US as the very good World Cup and Gold Cup tv ratings have shown.

    However, I don't think the only reason non-MLS supporting fans (aka EuroSnobs) haven't attached themselves to the new league is the level of play (real or perceived). To me, the culprits are the internets and satellite tv. A native of another country, or just a wannabe fan of a fashionable Premiership team, can follow their team from New York or Topeka as closely as if they were in London or Bogota.

  • 2

    But if you live in Kansas City you can't actually attend Barcelona or Inter or West Ham (!) matches on a regular basis. So if the quality and intensity of play in the MLS kept improving and, perhaps more importantly, the game atmosphere kept getting better as teams move out of big football stadiums into smaller soccer ones then more EuroSnobs will probably show up, right?

  • 3

    Justin,

    Don't get me wrong but MLS is still a very long way to become an appealing league. Football is still taking its first steps in the country and as for the pool of talent you mentioned... I am sorry but very few American players can actually cut it!
    Beckham and some over-the-hill superstars can give the sport a lift, but will it be THAT different than from playing in Saudi Arabia or Qatar?

    I can see the sports growing IF American becomes more passionate about it. Otherwise, the "Beckham effect" will soon be forgotten

  • 4

    A lot of the problem with soccer's popularity in this country is that it hasn't had time to become a generational thing. With North American football, kids have grown up with fathers and grandfathers who lived and died Bears football or Steelers football and that translates to their passionate love for the sport.

    With soccer, you can see this trend beginning in its earliest phases. Over time, as more and more people grow up immersed in the sport, it's popularity will grow as people come to understand its inherent beauty and near-perfect fusion of man and ball.

  • 5

    Sorry count me as a Eurosnob when it comes to soccer. To me it's not just about the availablity of soccer but it's about passion. When I watch a Man U/Liverpool game I know the rivalry is just as big as Yanks/Sox & Duke/UNC and that's something you just don't get with Galaxy/Red Bulls. Also a MAJOR problem for a lot of people is lack of scoring. I have friends who would much prefer to watch Lacrosse than soccer.

Add Your Comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.
The Curious Capitalist Daily E-mail

Get e-mail updates from TIME's The Curious Capitalist in your inbox and never miss a day.

Quotes of the Day »

Get & Share
LORI HAAS, whose daughter was wounded in the 2007 Virginia Tech shootings, on a new report finding that officials warned their families more than an hour and a half before the rest of the campus and released locked-down students who were later killed