Dutch Viacommer talks peace with YouTube
Sometimes people say really revealing things when they're talking in a language that they figure nobody outside their own country understands. This is from leading Dutch paper NRC Handelsblad (clunky translation mine):
According to Dan Ligtvoet, head of MTV Networks Benelux, the lawsuit filed by "big boss" Viacom is mainly a means of forcing new negotiations with YouTube. "I think that MTV and YouTube will be dependent upon each other in the future. They have to work together. MTV would be able to provide YouTube and other online channels, like MySpace and Hyves, with clips and other content. Just like we now deliver to the Xbox, the PlayStation or your mobile telephone."
I don't think YouTube really needs MTV's help to get music videos (it's YouTube's growing dominance in the music video space that the NRC article is mostly about), but I guess it would be interested in some of MTV's original programming. In any case, it's very interesting to hear someone inside the Viacom empire admit that the company "will be dependent upon" YouTube in the future.
-
1
On the surface this might just look like one super media outlet going after another for copyright infringement. And really, that's the claim. Viacom claims that Google's YouTube allowed copyrighted material (namely clips from Comedy Central programs "The Daily Show" and "The Colbert Report") on their site and then refused to take them down. Google responded that as soon as the clips were identified by Viacom they were removed.
Seems fairly straight forward, right? Well, not exactly. If you look a little deeper, Viacom didn't have a problem with the clips until it discovered that Google was generating advertising revenue through YouTube. Viacom decided that it wanted the advertising revenue instead (since apparently the paid advertisers and cable operating fees it already gets for the shows isn't enough). Therefore, Viacom demanded the clips be removed from YouTube (which was done) and decided to through its considerable assets behind (future) YouTube competitor Joost. Joost is a new startup that also looks to offer video content online, but by taking a big stake in Joost, Viacom has ensured that it will get a piece of the advertising revenue stream that Joost will generate.All right, again that might just seem like mere corporate greed, which it definitely is, but if that were all you probably wouldn't bat an eye. I mean, billionaires filing frivolous lawsuits against each other doesn't really effect the common man very much, does it? But wait, there's more.
Joost, it turns out, is the brainchild of the creators of file swapping software Kazaa (I'd provide a link but it's riddled with spyware). Kazaa, as you may recall, had the pants sued off it by the recording and motion picture studios, and had to pay damages to the tune of $100 million.
Perhaps now you're beginning to see the true picture of what is going on here. Viacom, as it turns out, owns several movie studios (including Paramount and Dreamworks) and also MTV and its music subsidiaries. Now, Viacom is suing Google for $1 billion in a bid, not for increased revenue, but to get something for nothing. If it prevails against Google, it can both pay its legal costs and also reimburse itself the investment money it poured into Joost. Joost, as it tuns out, was created by the very same people that Viacom was involved in suing out of existence (not to mention it helped so 10 year-olds for millions for using the Kazaa software) for enabling users to give content away for free.
This is, truly, the pinnacle of hypocrisy, to the point where Viacom is violating its own Business Conduct Statement. I guess in the world of mega-business, you are only responsible for sticking to your own stated code of conduct if the Feds are looking at you. Otherwise, you can throw them out the window to make a few extra dollars, all at the expense of the consumer (and really, who cares about them anyway?).
Most Popular »
- The Crimes and Misdemeanors of Meghan McCain
- The Discovery Gunman: TV as the Enemy, and as the Weapon
- A Few Thoughts on the God-Awful State of Customer Service
- Is red-hot India too hot?
- Hits and Misses from Today's Apple Announcement
- 18 Android Apps To Get You Started
- Call of Duty: Black Ops Multiplayer Offers Theater Mode, Wagering and More
- The 10 Tiny Details that Made Star Wars Matter
- Health Reform is Good for Small Business Employees
- The Obama Speech
- Tony Blair in 'A Journey': On U.S. Leaders Bush, Clinton
- Heavy Drinkers Outlive Nondrinkers, Study Finds
- Why Israelis Don't Care About Peace with Palestinians
- How Barack Obama Became Mr. Unpopular
- Study: Young, Single, Childless Women Earn More Than Men
- The Science of Ambition: How Genes, Family Affect Success
- Why France Is Deporting 700 Roma, or Gypsies, to Romania
- Arizona's Anti-Immigration Firebrands: Fueled by Out-of-Staters
- How Can a Democracy Solve Tough Problems?
- Cause of Death: Sloppy Doctors













RSS